Vibe coding influx on music machines

The news by Behringer announcing the Kick open source drum sampler, and a DJ  system with the same idea, quickly followed by Akai announcing that their Sample keys will also be open source (and probably the sample) has got me thinking.

We have also had a lot of reversed engineering on older machines from Akai S series sampler all the way to not so old gear from Elektron, all given new OS systems or firmware.

Cool right, on a first glance this may be the dream. If you think of a function or feature you can just add it. Or if you find a bug you can just fix it yourself and share it. Everything will go a lot faster.

(Open source) engineering your own ideas

But wasn’t this possible all along? Nobody would stop you if you wanted to build your own custom instrument, whether it be a sampler from scratch or working on building your own instruments in PureData, Supercollider or Max MSP and connecting it with a controller or building your own system from the ground up.

The thing has always been that this was pretty hard to do, not everyone has the time, energy or knowledge to start a project like this. The other part is, when developing your own ideas, these might not lead to the best device for you. You can only think of so much.

Even if you are an (software) engineer by trade you might not want to be bothered with (vibe) coding your own OS for all your devices, let alone firmwares.

You might just want to spent a night with a machine and make music. and take its quirks for granted. Working with machines designed by other people might give you a whole new range of ideas you might not have had when solely developing your own gear.

So this has always been possible, just not many people had the abundance of energy to go for it.

Design is important, and needs to be integral

A lot of devices start from a certain design esthetic, workflow idea or other main starting point. With hardware it’s not just building a nice box with buttons, thinking about how these interface with the software is very important to the success of the idea. It’s not two worlds apart.

Even if the layout is designed well, software design and making a great combination of hard and software requires more than just coding features. It’s thinking ahead when designing the hardware, it’s the total philosophy of the device. Workflow and all. Otherwise you would just end up with a controller and an empty computer and off you go.

So while these new developments seem great at a first glance, this might just lead to a load of not very well thought out boxes with a starting point for an OS and limited further development. And hopefully a community that drives the thing forward. A rather big gamble.

How many people who do not want to be an engineer in their free time and just want to make music, will be put off by this sudden influx of the “freedom of open source”. Even if you can vibe code the whole thing?

Doesn’t it undermine the whole concept of building well thought out instruments and technologies focussed on musicians that just want to learn a device and get on with making music? Do we really need all this perceived freedom? Limits are part of the creative process, and move ideas forward as much as endless possibilities.

Why do it?

We all know the feeling of buying an instrument and keep getting stuck in bugs, features that do not work and feel unfinished. Then over time, bug & feature requests hopefully lead towards new and improved software. Some companies do this pretty well and others die while trying. This can be very frustrating if you have one of these unfinished and abandoned products. So we could argue that open sourcing would be able to fix this.

On the flip side, companies can already use AI to improve the software development process and deliver bug fixes faster and ship with less bugs in the first place, so why bother open sourcing it? Just incorporate it into your development.

Less is more

Back to the bright side, features. Why not just let everyone develop their own ideas and work on features, so we can all benefit from it? Well keeping the integrity of an idea and workflow also means not developing some feature requests as the get in the way of the workflow, the core of what an instrument needs to do. Less is truly more. We all have software like Ableton where we only use a part of, there is a reason not everyone goes for large open ended systems like Max MSP, Supercollider or PureData. It’s too much. Too many options, too many ideas that can be crammed into one system. Design is also about restraint. Developing something with limits so people can get creative with them.

If you want to develop your own instruments with loads of features, you can, even more so in this day and age of AI. Why should manufacturers of instruments build open ended boxes?

Build it! From scratch

I am very in favor of open source, engineering your own tools and designing cool stuff. Especially now this is more accessible than ever before. With AI, workshops  on engineering, printing and manufacturing small batches being readily available. But it is still hard, you need to work on skills and work on a design philosophy and set limits at some point. If you want to do that, do it build stuff from scratch.

For the pure joy of making music, I think getting your hands on a few well build and well designed pieces of gear is the way to go. So we need company’s that have that design philosophy, do the hard part and develop, maintain and bring those ideas further. Otherwise we all be stuck in our own minds and my bet is there will be a lot less cool instruments if we let everything go in an early stage and not do the hard work.

Lazy creative Sundays

Keeping any rhythm in anything seems a bit hard the last year or so. Partly because I have no clear idea of what I want to be doing with my creative outlets, writing and music being the most important, but also coding.

My main go to method is making plans, setting consistency markers and making sure I show up. Well, showing up is the hard part at the moment. Most of the time consistency and showing up are my strong points. Finishing and sharing my weak ones. Everything in between mostly takes care of itself.

Thinking of this dilemma on a lazy Sunday, whilst Autumn has finally arrived, I thought why not write about it.

It’s funny how my energy levels decide whether I am able to show up to the creative parts of my life while on the other hand providing me with energy. Having no energy to begin makes this somewhat hard.

Loving something enough to do it, doesn’t automatically mean I can devote all or a big part of my energy towards these things. Life has some more ordinary tasks as well.

This made me realize that I might need to be doing smaller increments and clear some lazy Sundays and make them lazy creative Sundays. Just writing with a pen and paper with no other intention than getting words on a blank piece of paper. Or writing a single beat on a drummachine.

Rigoureus planning is helping me a lot in daily life and I have been trying the same tactic in the creative domain, which might not be the way to go. It’s not something I really need to do to keep my life going, and the end of the day these are all just, beautiful, hobby’s. There is no need to work on them as if it’s a job or daily must.

Losing the more rigorous side of planning and just carve out time to do anything creative just might do the trick, in getting back to consistency. Time will tell, I am giving it a go.

Returning to old habits

I have been away for a quite a while. Figuring out what I want to do creatively and making some time for other things. I have been doing more offline stuff but I like publishing stuff. Even if it’s just some random thoughts on life.

But I need some form of consistency again and regular writing is a nice way to get into it again. On the music front I have mainly been doodling around with Eurorack and getting lost in patching, which has been fun. I still struggle with finishing music and looking for ways to limit time spent on one project.

Reading interesting books on creativity led me to the book written by Rick Rubin, the creative act, a way of being. Which goes into the creativity and the proces, not just interesting for all artist but everyone, as we all do a lot of creative stuff in our lives.

The book ranges from practical tips to more philosophical musings around creativity. It’s an easy read and everyone will find something in this book. So if you are looking for a nice holiday book, this can be it.

I am hoping this new start will be the beginning of an old habit returning even if it’s just for myself. Then again I hope you will find it an entertaining read.

Slowing down is helping a lot.

It’s been a while, not much to talk about and not much progress in the creative areas as in finished projects, however small.

Is that a bad thing? No, I have been slowing down a lot and have been working on my projects without any planning, just keeping the focus on consistency. I have also been outside a lot, walking around, running, and sitting down with a book. Logging off, and making sure I enjoy everything. 

A strange phenomenon of the modern times is that we are communicating a lot and doing less actual work. Contemplating and thinking requires focus, rest and breathing room. Doomscrolling and other digital addictions only distract from consistent work, and doing nothing is an integral part of the process. 

It might be viewed as a badge of honor and work ethic to always be (extremely) busy and planning the calendar as full as possible. All of which is counter productive. 

I have done more in way less time this period and enjoying things much more. As I am no longer striving for the maximum result, which mostly meant planning as much time as I could manage on every activity and forgetting to take enough breaks to digest and process my ideas, thinking and learning. And while I already planned breaks and rest, this was just too rigid. 

The biggest problem as always is keeping the balance and flow. But skipping a lot of distractions has helped a lot. Even as simple as taking a nice walk without your phone is a great idea. Maybe a dumb phone is an idea? Anyway until next time. 

Art & income, the finance of art

This week has seen the demise of Aslice gaat stoppen. Aslice  was all about creating a more equal pay for musicians, for a fairer distribution of the revenue from music. Via a community driven structure.

There is a very big discrepancy between the income made by the artists who make the music (producers) and the people making a living out of playing the music (Dj’s). It’s not a coincidence you need to be a DJ/Producer nowadays to generate any income from making music.

The idea was pretty simple, Dj’s send in their playlists and from those lists the producers of the music get a paid an amount for each time a track is played. This means the Dj will make a little bit less, but the producer gets a change to have an income out of their music.

Not all Dj’s are big earners, and many struggle to get a decent wage out of it. You can still read everything there is to know about Aslice and their system om the website. But this brings up a bigger question there is in the arts in general, not just music, but writers, sculptors and painters and so on. All these people have trouble living of just their art. And have all sorts of jobs on the side.

Aslice & the importance of community

The biggest problem (in retrospect) for Aslice was the absence of a lot of Dj’s and mainly the bigger names and highest paid people in the industry. The problem with those people not signing up is that you miss a lot of revenue which should go back to the producers. But also in the lower echelons of the income pyramid it missed the volume to really make a breakthrough.

But why is a more equal distribution important? Everyone can go for their own succes by working on their own channels for revenue? Yes, these are options. The only problem is by doing this individually you can never reach all the corners of the eco system. You simply don’t know if someone is playing your music if they don’t tell you. Instead of being able to let the music work for you after you released it, by letting others play it (in other words sell it), you have to go out there and do this all by yourself. By playing the music yourself or do other activities to sell yourself.

The problem being, there is a limit to what the individual can produce as output.  There is a limited amount of time, and energy one can produce. And as a musician this isn’t your job, your job is to make new music. The Aslice system provided a way for musicians to generate income from music when other people went on and did their thing with it. I.e do their job. Making music is not a hobby, as an artist you have to be able to generate income from your music. And not just when you are at the top of the pyramid. Aslice provided a revenue stream without the artists having to put in time to generate it. Passive income.

An eco system can’t function if only a small minority profits at the expense of the work of all the others in the eco system (otherwise known as a community). This inevitably  leads to a hollowing out of that system. Artists drop out and no new ones can join. And some point the eco system collapses and a barren land is what is left. You can’t participate if you can’t live from an eco system. It’s that simple.
You can’t reach your full potential if you can’t work on your greatest skill, and have to to all sorts of side hustles to keep afloat.

Individuality & the illusion of succes

This is a problem in the whole of society, in the last 30 years or so this has become the main issue. The belief succes of the individual is solely the outcome of choices and changes that individual has made and taken. Throughout society the illusion that succes is a choice. Whatever is going on outside the circle of influence and the outside world. Just work ‘hard enough’ and seize ‘opportunities’ and you will reap the rewards.

This is only partly true, you can only be as successful as your environment is. Maybe a small percentage can fight their way out of a position of disadvantage, but the first thing they do is leave the place where opportunities are slim.

Succes, for the most part, is the outcome of great communities and solid infrastructures. You simply can’t do everything on your own. A society can’t function without education, health care, affordable living, access to food and so on. These things form the foundation for the individuals to thrive, the access to this infrastructure needs to be organized in such a way, that the majority of participants in these communities have acces to it and be able to use it.

You will have to work on, maintain and build these infrastructures before you can become successful as an individual. Every member needs to make a small contribution to this infrastructure and help others to become successful in order to stay successful themselves. The most well known way to organize this is paying taxes. It’s that simple.

The arts and the revenue model

The world of arts has been plagued by declining in funding the last few decades. All emphasis was placed on building your own revenue models. A lot of subsidies which maintained a lot of the infrastructures, think public venues, studios, art centers and educational systems have been minimized or downright cut all together. Which implicitly meant the art community had to fend for itself. A fairer distribution of the revenue generated with the art becomes crucial.

By subsidizing important parts of the eco system, the money involved becomes almost invisible. People pay taxes for all sorts of things and don’t think about what is funded with the money. This makes a lot of people even wary of paying them. Most people can only think about the stuff they don’t want funded by taxes.  That’s why the democratic process is important. But that’s another matter altogether, the simple fact is, the lack of togetherness, which has crept in, in the vast majority of society is also very prevalent in the art world. It wasn’t easy making a living from arts before and it certainly isn’t now. The community in the arts world has vanished.

The revenue stream, and the value broader society has for arts & culture has declined. And therefore the system fails for individual artists to make a living. The revenue model has shifted towards the individual, it’s not the art that needs selling, it’s the individual. Things like the 1000 follower principle, where 1000 people pay 1000 dollars a year and generate an income that way solely hinges on the individual to be able to generate art (or mostly content).

This immediately comes to an halt when that individual has a calamity and can’t make any more music (or content) and the revenue streams stops. There are no safety nets within the system. The most hearth-wrenching examples are the Gofundme pages where artists seek help in paying for cost of living and medical bills ones they fall ill. Nevermind paying for their recovery. Passive revenue from songs played is an absolute necessity.

There is a massive limit in earning power of an individual, this is true for everyone, but especially artists, where art needs to be sold, in this case music played before any revenue is generated. For musicians music played needs to be a valid stream of income. But they can’t live off albums alone anymore. And this is a big risk, it takes a lot of time working on an album and the only way to pay for this time is by the music being played when the music goes out into the world.

Once it’s out there, a lot of the revenue sticks to the top of the pyramid. The balance within the revenue stream is off. A fairer distribution is why a platform such as Aslice is important.

Community back on the agenda

Technology enables us to quickly build a solution which when carried by a large part of the community can restore the balance in revenue pretty quickly. So everyone can carve out their piece of the pie and keep going, and add too the community and eco system. We just need to instill a realization that everyone has their fair value within the eco system. Not just a shout out on social media, but a simple small amount whenever you use a track someone has made. These are not big numbers, it’s about volume.

Technology can help us work out the distribution, the how of the equation. But for things to truly happen we need the majority of the community involved. This can only be reached if we put the topic of the community back on the agenda. Within industry gatherings we not only need to talk about the branding of the artist on an individual level, but talk about a healthy eco system and community as well. How we build, maintain and develop the eco system and subsequently the community.

And not just about the fun stuff, like making music together, collabs with instrument builders and so on, but be frank about the numbers, the accounting behind it all. The “boring” bits. The risks of being a one person company as most artists are. And the risks involved when you do not get paid enough for your work. The bullet points below are just a few of the risks.

      • Insufficient income for health insurance.
      • Insufficient income  for periods with less gigs, or to buy insurance against income drops.
      • Insufficient income for building up a pension.
      • Insufficient income for insurance against disability.

And these are just the individual risks, some risks for the eco system

      • No new or improved venues for younger talent to work and perform
      • No real networks are maintained as everyone is to busy making ends meet.
      • No synergy and scale advantages that a healthy eco system provides for growth and future proofing of the eco system.

It’s not just about money

A community has a lot advantages for people who are part of such an eco system. You can grow your craft a lot faster you can focus on your skillset and not worry too much about other things. Everyone can learn and feed off each other and grow organically. Being part of a community is essential. For these systems to be able to flourish everyone has to contribute some of there time and energy towards that community. In a society this is done via taxes, we then pay other people with other skills to run the eco system. Now the world of arts need to do this themselves. The ‘invisible’ part in the form of subsidies is no longer there. The creative community might have gotten used to this too much, who knows. But in the current political and economical landscape you can’t count on this anymore. The creative community needs to organize this themselves. We need to make sure the eco system is healthy.

The most important thing for people to be able to contribute is that the revenue is divided fairly among the participants, so we can all work on the pillars of the system, such as education, safe spaces to work and crate, get together and interact. So everyone can work on their craft and be able to excel as much as possible and cover the basic risks.

Aslice had a great model to achieve just that. For everyone to be able to make a decent living and thus can dedicate some of their every to build a community in which everyone can work and make a living of their art.

For society as a whole this is very important, as art pays a big part in letting people be able to think critically and provide safe places for people in oppression. As a society we simply can’t progress without art. That’s why the art community has to take a hard look in the mirror and realize the need to work on the eco system and community as absolutely essential.

 

Simple creative tasks, consistent.

Last week In talked about simplifying my setup and designing a proces to be more consistent. This article is more about the proces and why it works. While I am learning to use my music gear I have also set some small tasks to keep things interesting and work on finishing stuff. I do well when I set goals for myself. My biggest flaw in setting these goals in making them way too big. Where my goals far outstripped my skillset.

So I have decided to simplify my goals, or rather just make tasks out of them. so for each week I have set the following goals. With my simple set-up, I will try and finish these tasks every week. You can’t really call the results tracks maybe, but I will try my best to keep it as interesting as possible. within the parameters I have set for myself.

The main goal is learning to be fluent with my simple setup and be able to work on ideas at a faster pace. Science shows that in order to keep yourself engaged the things you need to do to make progress is to have a difficulty sweet spot. If something is too easy, you will disengage. If it’s too hard, you will also disengage. It’s human nature.  There is a side note to this, more on that later. 

Creating habits is all about doing something consistently and keep doing it. To be better at making music, I need to be making music. Taking into account it should not be too easy or too hard my tasks should be just about doable. 

So I will learn and keep having fun and feel excited. Everyone has big goals, but if it’s way too hard we can’t form the habits necessary for achieving them. Last week an already shared some idea around a set of steps to achieve this. 

Here is my slightly refined taks list.

1. Create a patch on my small eurorack setup
2. Record loops while playing the patch
3. Take a maximum of 8 loops in the Ableton template.
4. Arrange and finish the recordings. 
5. Publish the results.

By sharing them I have also set a nice little reminder for myself to publish things consistently, so people can give me feedback and get over my fear of sharing my musical experiments. 

The side note is that every process has boring parts that are necessary to get better. So this means we also need some tolerance for boredom. So if something gets boring at any stage, we tend to go and look for something exciting and new.

The key difference in being successful in getting better at your skill and creating habits is that you embrace the boredom which ultimately creeps into everything. Some stuff just needs doing. No matter what. It’s all part of the process. People who succeed in showing up when feeling bored, or tired or any state that doesn’t fill you with enthusiasm to go to work, people who still show up, succeed. 

It’s a bit of a balancing act, creating habits and paving the way towards your goal and being able to consistently work on your goals. The mantra “Don’t break the chain” is a simple way to remind yourself to stick to the plan. If you don’t feel like doing music, go to the gym or any other task you planned. Just remind yourself and repeat this mantra a few times to yourself. It will help to reaffirm your commitment to the proces, and the habit you are developing and maintaining. 

Last but not least, we also need to evaluate, learn and make things a bit harder again at some point. So we can work on improvement with some new challenges. 

Consistency has helped me with achieving other goals in life, so now it’s time to make it work for my musical journey. 

Quantity over quality

One of the things I doubt is the quality of my creative output. Whether it’s my writing, my pictures or my writing skills, I often have doubts about the quality of the work. Especially with my music, and the main reason I almost never share anything.

I really want to change this. I strive for perfection in everything and while pursuing perfection I often trow away ideas or keep tweaking to find it. For some reason I am more easy going in other areas, like writing. Probably because I feel I am somewhat better at it which makes it easier for me to share.

Society teaches us that everything must be ‘perfect’, what this ‘perfect’ is nobody tells you. And while striving for perfection a lot of good ideas are lost and the art of experimentation is lost.

Science teaches us something else. If you want to be good at something, you need to practice a lot. You increase your skills by doing and while doing you learn from your mistakes. By sharing your work you give others the opportunity to give feedback, which is another opportunity to learn.

In Japan it’s very normal to accept the beauty of imperfection, wabi-sabi, the acceptance and transience of imperfection. In art it’s often described as ‘imperfect beauty’ or ‘flawed beauty’ it emphasizes the process of making a piece of art resulting in an art piece that is ultimately incomplete.

We don’t have this in western cultures, which is a real shame. Our need for perfection puts the break on our output. Or as Voltaire said it “the best is the enemy of the good”. Things don’t have to be perfect. In life and especially in all forms of creative output perfection is a debatable concept.

So why do I struggle so much with sharing my music? I think it is because music is very valuable to me. I have so much great memories attached to music. and music has gotten me through some hard times that all my musical output seems pale in comparison, will it ever be good enough to evoke any emotion?

This sounds a bit heavy but that’s how I feel about it. I need to let this feeling go and start sharing my creations. Even if it’s just a loop or an unfinished piece of music. Striving for perfection is something I need to let go and focus on improving by making a lot of stuff. Quantity over quality, in order to improve my skills and let go of my fear of sharing. The quality will come over time.

Less is more

The larger the setup the more options I have. Which I absolutely love. However this also has a time implication, more of my limited time and energy will go into setting up and learning how to use it. I have tried to use a limited set of tools before which quickly escalated into much larger setups.

I am not very good in keeping a small setup and focussing on just that setup. Which is a bit weird as my discipline is pretty good. I can keep to my planning. I suppose this is because I love my toys. I am like a little kid in a toy store which is allowed to play with anything. And this does not yield any result. Just a lot of unfinished sketches.

So this time I absolutely need to keep my setup small and learn it inside out. which will be my focus the coming month. I keep my timelines a bit wider as last time I got frustrated with not achieving my goals. In retrospect I had too many things I wanted to get done in too little time.

This time that has to change. There is a lot to do which will take time. That’s just how it is.

The music journey – Making an album (week 15)

The move to a minimal setup continuous, spend this week with the Moog Mother-32 and the Digitakt. Haven’t recorded anything remotely resembling a song but have been learning these 2 machines a bit better. It’s really funny how my initial idea of minimal was way to big. And now this setup has defined minimal for me again.

In a related way I have started looking at the album project. Which will remain intact. But lacked a sufficient foundation in skills. Coincidently I have been setting up a project at work which needed a solid dive back into the books, mainly the theories on design. From the broader aspect of design down, via design principles down to the day to day design decisions we all need to make.

In order to get that project going I need to build a basic model of all functions in that system, in such a way that it runs from the start. So a lot of effort is going into making the framework and the proces design. The detail will fill itself in later.

This got me thinking on my own proces in making this album, It lacks the correct framework, the basic design idea & concept are there but the music making framework isn’t working yet. I can’t get ideas out of my head fast enough. Especially considering the limited time I can spent with full cognitive functions on making music.

So the focus needs to be on getting to know the tools a lot better and get it to such a level I can get ideas out very fast. So that’s going to be the goal for the next few weeks (al least).

Max MSP project – Open source and the learning curve.

For ages I have MAX/MSP by Cycling 74 installed om my machine and from time to time I am completely obsessed with the endless possibilities which exists in this space. For the ones not familiar with Max, it’s a developing tool for creating anything relating to producing music and integrating visuals. From synthesizers to art installation stuff. And everything in between.

And that’s exactly where my problem manifests itself, it’s just too much. However small I begin, I always get lost. Lost in my own brain to be more exact. And then I stop with pursuing and learning. I have not been able to let it go or start in a direction to try and really push it.

So the idea behind this series is to get more grip on my own learning proces and share everything I learn. I will post it on this blog and I will put stuff in a , yet to put up, GitHub page.

The ultimate goal is to build an interactive looper for live use. A looper which takes the input from my Eurorack synthesizer and takes that input and loops it. Which I can then further manipulate. I will share all my progress (or lack of) , and will share all my notes, first designs and the road when building the patch itself. And ultimately also the music that comes out of the proces.

That’s the main goal , every time I test the patch a series of recordings emerge. I will not share all of them, just the ones at the end of each stage. And that I think are worthwhile sharing.

This might result is a nice collection of useful notes on my own personal learning method, a nice max patch and enough music to compile an album with.

A big project indeed, but by working this way I hope to get into a rhythm and work on it more consistent. On all of it, learning, music and sharing.